Start or Bench Posts
LEAGUE SETTINGS
Team:
12
Scoring Type:
Head-to-Head
Keeper:
Yes
Passing Yards
25 Yds = 1 Pt
Pass TD
4 Pts
Interceptions
-2 Pts
Rushing Yards
10 Yds = 1 Pt
Rush TD
6 Pts
Receiving Yards
10 Yds = 1 Pt
Receiving TD
6 Pts
LINEUP
QB - Kevin Kolb (PHI)
RB - Maurice Jones-Drew (JAC)
RB - Chris Wells (ARI)
WR - Reggie Wayne (IND)
WR - Michael Crabtree (SF)
RB/WR - Dwayne Bowe (KC)
TE - Jermichael Finley (GB)
K - Mason Crosby (GB)
DL - Mathias Kiwanuka (NYG)
DL - Darnell Dockett (ARI)
DB - Antoine Bethea (IND)
DB - Brian Dawkins (DEN)
LB - Karlos Dansby (ARI)
LB - James Laurinaitis (STL)
BN - Ben Roethlisberger (PIT)
BN - Rashad Jennings (JAC)
BN - Carnell Williams (TB)
BN - Vincent Jackson (SD)
BN - Sidney Rice (MIN)
BN - Eddie Royal (DEN)
BN - Ndamukong Suh (DET)
tpoucher
Kolb or Ryan for Keeper QB?
I'm torn. I want Matt Ryan to be the elite QB that he should be. Berry has him ranked 16th at QB, while Kolb breaks the top 10 at QB9. Do I keep Kolb and pray?
NFL 2010 Pre-Season
  48 Views  
by tpoucher 06/29/2010  
Players to Choose From
Matt Ryan, QB (ATL) - BYE
Kevin Kolb, QB (PHI) - BYE
PULSE
Ryan
4
Kolb
2
Sound Off On This Post!
(Please pick 1!)

1024 characters left.
User Comments
Pages:    1      Previous   |   Next
LakeShow0824 (7 FANS)
I agree with Werker, it's starts with MJD then it's everyone else. Considering you only start 1 QB, you may be even pick up Kolb in a later round. Not to mention in your scoring format its only 4 points/TD pass.. That makes RBs more valuable than QBs in your league. The choice is MJD over the quarterbacks. But for what it's worth, if you're still inclined to keep a QB, it's definitely Matt Ryan over Kolb.
Posted: 07/20/2010
Werker (20 FANS)
Matt Ryan
In keeper value, I'd rank your team like this: MJD, Wells, Crabtree, Finley, Ryan, Kolb, Wayne, Bowe, Wallace, Forsett, and a bunch of guys no one would waste a top 6 keeper pick on. If you're more concerned with this year than the future, I'd put Wayne in front of Crabtree. So I'd definitely keep MJD, Wells, Crabtree, Finley and Ryan and then it's a call of future or present with Kolb or Wayne. What I'd really suggest doing is finding a guy with only 4 or 5 legit keepers and trading 2 or 3 for 1 to get a top 5 RB or WR. You have the best keeper TE in the league with Finley, so I'd protect him, MJD, Crabtree and Wells who you're just not going to get enough value to warrant trading. Package any combo of the other guys to upgrade.
Posted: 07/20/2010
Answer Werker's latest post: HUGE trade help - WHIR
dshave7 (7 FANS)
Matt Ryan
i like ryan more, kolb does have weapons but he cant throw the deep ball to d-jax
Posted: 07/18/2010
Answer dshave7's latest post: Which QB to start?
tpoucher (98 FANS)
Anyone else? Please help me.
Posted: 07/18/2010
Answer tpoucher's latest post: RB Starters
Bs Nuttz (22 FANS)
Keep MJD, Wells, Crabtree, Wayne, Bowe, and Forsett. There are many other QBs that can be drafted later than these guys and still put up comparable numbers. Wayne kind of gives me concerns as well because of his age and Indianapolis army of recievers: Wayne, Collie, Garcon, Gonzalez, Clark, and Addai. You might even want to think about keeping Wallace instead of Wayne. Wallace had flashes of Pro Bowl material last season as a number 3 reciever. With Ward getting older and Holmes shipping out, Wallace should be able to capitalize with some big fantasy games. In the long run I like Wallace over Wayne only because of the age difference. Wayne for this year obviously, but in Dynasty I would keep Wallace.
Posted: 07/15/2010
Answer Bs Nuttz's latest post: Who to start?
GR Punks Says:
Matt Ryan
Id say Ryan is the safe pick, but Kolb has potentially more reward. Help my baseball question?
Posted: 07/15/2010
Answer GR Punks's latest post: Middle Infield Dilemma
tpoucher (98 FANS)
REALLY need some more input. Struggling with this one. MJD, Beanie Wells, Reggie Wayne, D. Bowe and Crabtree plus one of these two... or keep Finley over both QBs, or keep Forsett or Mike Wallace...
Posted: 07/15/2010
Answer tpoucher's latest post: RB Starters
BRTZKTH Says:
Kevin Kolb
Kolb has so many weapons around him, I think he will have a huge year.
Posted: 06/30/2010
Answer BRTZKTH's latest post: who to start
Bs Nuttz (22 FANS)
Matt Ryan
I think you have to keep Ryan. You know what you are getting with him. He will get you 18 pts a game with the possiblitiy of averaging in the low 20's. Kolb is a toss up. He could give you around what Ryan will give you, maybe slightly better, or he could be a huge bust. It is enough to pass on Kolb and take the for sure player in Ryan.
Posted: 06/29/2010
Answer Bs Nuttz's latest post: Who to start?
RedRook (2 FANS)
Kevin Kolb
That's a hard one, and I think it depends on if you're going for a starter or a backup, and how prone towards risk you want to be. Kolb is totally feast or famine, and will make or break your team as a starter. On the other hand, you know what you're getting with Ryan - a good secondary QB that will light up against a few matchups. What does the QB situation look like across the league? Would you be in a situation where, if you kept Kolb, you'd be able to fill in with a good secondary QB? Or will you have the opportunity to draft a better starter if you keep Ryan? It's definitely a keep one/sell one scenario, as they both bye at 8. All other things equal, I'd take Kolb. If he does well, you'll be set. If he doesn't, you can probably get a QB around Ryan's draft level in a trade for a backup WR/RB.
Posted: 06/29/2010
Answer RedRook's latest post: Mauer <--> Zimmerman/Garcia?
Pages:    1      Previous   |   Next